Genealogical Proof Standard

Genealogical Proof Standard(GPS) has replaced the former Preponderance of the Evidence (POE) standard for evaluation of genealogical research conclusions. The new standard is actually higher than the former, more legal standard that had been used traditionally. I just read Christine Rose's book: Genealogical Proof Standard: Building a Solid Case over the weekend and wanted to recommend it to you as through, well illustrated with examples and logical in its presentation.

Ms. Rose covers direct versus indirect evidence, original versus derivative sources, and primary versus secondary information, even on "sticky" records, such as death certificates and censuses. The steps to reach a solid conclusion are explained and an examination of weighing the various records through case studies are presented. She especially stresses the need for a written conclusion, both for the researcher to present the solid case and for future researchers. I was especially pleased that she believes, as I do, that it is just as important to present the disproved theories and your conclusion as the solid theory that you have confidence in as a researcher.